Tale One: Big Tree, Big Axe. Cleveland Botanical Garden has a row of maturing, healthy Norway maples (Acer platanoides) growing along East Boulevard. And we are cutting them down.
Actually native to Norway and across northern Europe, the Norway maple has a detailed association with humans. If never a lumber tree, it has long been valued for fine carpentry and horticulture. In early 1700s Italy, Antonio Stradivari probably made the back boards for his supreme violins from Norway maple. By the mid 1700s Norways had crossed the Atlantic to appear in Colonial seed lists; there is a 1756 record of one being planted in Philadelphia. Norways were popular in 1800s New England as garden fancies (curiously, all our trees came from English nurseries, where Norway maple is non-native, so we have no wild provenance on U.S. stocks).
But it took Dutch elm disease of the 1930s to bring the Norway maple to its current prominence in the northeastern U.S. This disease that devastated our native American Elm (Ulmus americana) created a huge void in our street tree population, a void that was filled by existing nursery stock in the form of the Norway. And it was a good elm substitute, for it was found to be easy to commercially re-propagate in a hurry, to transplant well, to grow vigorously on site, and to have tremendous tolerance of urban environments.
But the Norway also makes impenetrable canopy shade, throws copious fertile seed, and chemically inhibits competing seedlings. This suite of traits both “good” and “bad” soon helped the Norway become—you guessed it—a woody weed.
So here at the Garden, we had three Norway maples removed (I can’t say “felled” since they were hoisted up from their stumps and craned out of the garden) the week before last. In the coming years, more will be removed. And we already have a plan for the sunny slope they are leaving behind. Our Woodland gardener has selected a swath of flowering shrubs, small trees, ferns and wildflowers to grow and thrive in this space. The emphasis is on native plants, but there are exceptions; the design is naturalistic, but with an artistic gleam. So watch this space with some anticipation. Coming soon are flame azaleas and rosebay rhododendrons, native silverbell and spirea, hay-scented fern and fragrant sumac; a hillside painting in the sunshine.
Look around you. If you have an ornamental maple in your yard with burgundy, bronze or chartreuse foliage, it is a Norway hybrid. I don’t loathe the Norway so much as respect its potential. Like all weeds, to me it is half-terror, half-teacher.
Tal
e Two: Big Tree, Small Axe. Cleveland Botanical Garden has a nice Chestnut Oak (Quercus prinus) at the edge of the Restorative Garden, and right now it is dropping twigs damaged by a girdling beetle.
The flat-headed longhorn oak girdling beetle (poss. Oncideres quercus) probably won’t kill the tree. But over the past few years of infestation it has already disfigured its twigs, by inducing hundreds of haphazard, zigzag re-growths. And I have been taught by experience that one tree stress often invites others, which add up to sometimes deadly arithmetic.
This beautiful little creature wears wing covers that look as if they are made from hammered lead, and sprouts segmented, elegantly curved antennae that extend from flat head halfway to pointy tail. It leads a peculiar and particular life. The little twig tips littering the ground today were fashioned last autumn into nursery chambers by the adult beetles. The adults chewed “girdling” rings into their twigs, and then laid a few to a few dozen eggs under the bark of each of their outrigger twigs. The adults
soon died, but their eggs hatched within the twigs, and spent the winter as larvae, nestled and safe up in the tree. With this spring’s winds and rain, the girdled—and killed—twigs are now snapping free from their moorings, and falling to the garden floor. And it is down here that the oak girdling beetle larvae begin to feed for a few weeks, eating their nursery walls. They then pupate, again in their original twig chambers. By mid-summer, the flying adults will hatch, eat some green wood, mate, and girdle more living chestnut oak twigs to complete their annual life cycle. I will collect some twig tips, keep them contained, and see if I can capture one of the hatching adults this summer. If successful, I will post pictures here.
Common in Ohio, I see evidence of the oak girdling beetle every year in chestnut oaks, white oaks (Quercus alba), and bur oaks (Quercus macrocarpa), too. Bur oak twigs snap off a few months from now; is the wood perhaps more durable, or does bur oak bear a different species of beetle?
If you have girding beetles living in your oak, don’t fret. Tend to the tree’s general health and it will withstand the infestation. Don’t compact your oak tree’s soil or cut its roots, and don’t mulch it too heavily. Prune damaged wood that might invite secondary disease. And collect and destroy all the fallen twigs, so removing the next generation of beetles in the process.
Oaks have co-evolved along with a host of voracious native insects. For their half of this never-ending pull-and-tug, oaks manufacture an array of tannins and possibly lignins for chemical defense. Nevertheless, an oak un-blighted by apple gall wasps, oak leaf rollers, or girdling beetles seems unusual to me. They must be generous trees, and surely the flat-headed longhorn oak girdling beetle is fortunate for this bounty.
There you go: Two Cutting Tree Tales; Or, What I Saw In The Garden.
Posted by Mark Bir